Crit & Fumble

Grab your Weapons

Join the Crit & Fumble crew in a cavalcade of chaos as they battle through the Underworld, set sail upon seas of the dead, and take a road trip to find Bigfoot. Whether it’s D&D or another RPG, find your chaos in Crit & Fumble’s weekly actual play TTRPG podcast!

Listen on Spotify All Our Shows

The Crew

Gavin Vickery

Cat Herder

Gavin, an avid board gamer, always wanted to try D&D but lacked players. So, he learned to DM and nagged his friends to join. Five years later, they still play every Sunday, and he wouldn’t change a thing.

Chelsea Oaten

Maven of Mystery

Chelsea careened into the C&F table in 2023 and just never left. When she’s not making NPCs for the party to love/hate, you can find her scheming over backstories, painting minis, and planning plot twists. Faaantastic.

Tash Baycroft

Pixel Pusher

Tash is an OG member of Crit & Fumble. He owns zero fedoras but loves playing make-believe, speaking in funny voices, and bringing creative energy to every adventure.

Russ Morland

Aesthetic Architect

Defender of Good Times. Champion of getting shit done.

Sean Murray

Sometimes Daddy

Sean started playing advanced pretend back in 2004 and has been playing with the fumble family since 2023. When not testing out spooky ttrpg systems he’s painting minis, making maps, or lifting rocks.

Dwayne Orser

Snack Master

Dwayne helps provide a well balanced meal of sugar, cheeses, meats, crackers, licorice and Bublys. These are the six basic food groups recommended by the C&FG, recommending that moderation is over rated.

Neil Gaudet

Captain Oblivious

An OG member, Neil’s characters span from Renago to Obsidian to Grigori. Now a guest star, his rare visits bring delight, drama, and occasional dismay to our table.

Our Shows

Learn more about our shows

Crit & Fumble

This is where it all started—and where you’ll find our main campaigns. Crit & Fumble is a space where storytelling knows no boundaries. Our approach is all about embracing the wacky, the wild, and the unexpected.

Listen to Crit & Fumble

Short Shots

Short Shots is here to flip the script on traditional RPGs. We believe that not every role-playing adventure needs to span a hundred sessions—sometimes, the best stories are told in a few short, exciting bursts.

Coming May 2025!

Listen to Short Shots

Tales from the Table

ales from the Table is your all-access pass to the stories behind our stories. Every campaign we run is packed with twists, surprises, and deep lore—some of which even our own players miss.

Listen to Tales from the Table